Compare the 28 days since the drop with the 28 days before, query by query, in Search Console’s Performance report. If impressions and position held and clicks fell, an AI Overview is the likely cause. If position fell, you lost rankings, which needs a different fix. If impressions fell and position held, fewer people searched.
What does a click lost to an AI Overview look like in Search Console?
Search Console treats the overview as one result. A click on a link inside it counts as a click, and every link in it gets the overview’s position. You can’t see the lost click itself. You can see what each cause of a drop does to four numbers: clicks, impressions, click rate (CTR) and average position.
Three causes of a drop, three patterns
| What happened | Clicks | Impressions | CTR | Position |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The overview took the click | 120 → 70 | 4,000 → 4,100 | 3.0% → 1.7% | 3.1 → 3.0 |
| You lost rankings | 120 → 40 | 4,000 → 1,900 | 3.0% → 2.1% | 3.1 → 8.4 |
| Fewer people searched | 120 → 80 | 4,000 → 2,700 | 3.0% → 3.0% | 3.1 → 3.2 |
One case looks odd. If the overview cites your page, your link gets the overview’s position, which can be higher than your own result below it. So your average position can go up while your clicks go down. Read that the same way as the first row: your page is shown, and people stop at the answer.
One search, two positions for your page
How do you check it in Search Console?
- Open Performance, then Search resultsTurn on all four numbers: total clicks, total impressions, average CTR and average position.
- Compare two date rangesUnder Date, pick Compare, then the 28 days since the drop against the 28 days before. Start both ranges on the same weekday. If your traffic moves with the seasons, compare with the same 28 days last year instead.
- Sort the queries by lost clicksOn the Queries tab, sort by the click difference. Take the 20 queries that lost the most and match each one to a row in the table above.
- Look at the Pages tabIf the drop sits on one page, check that page in URL Inspection before you blame anything else. A redirect or a page that fell out of the index looks like a ranking loss.
- Check the dateLook up the day the drop started on Google’s list of ranking updates. Google’s November 2026 core update started on November 10, so a drop that began that week may be the update, not the overview.
- Search your top lost queries yourselfIn a private window, search the five queries that lost the most clicks. Note whether an AI Overview shows and whether it links to you. No overview on a search means the overview didn’t take that click.
What does Search Console’s AI report show?
Since August 31, 2026, every site in Search Console has the Generative AI performance reports. They show how often your pages appeared in Google’s AI features: AI Overviews and AI Mode in Search, and the AI features in Discover. You can split them by page, country and date, and by device for Search.
They show impressions only. No clicks, no position. The same impressions also count in your regular Performance report, so never add the two together.
That still answers half the question: is the overview showing your page? If a page’s AI impressions rise while its clicks fall, you’re in the answer and people aren’t clicking through. If a page lost clicks and has no AI impressions, the overview isn’t citing you. Our guide to measuring AI visibility covers the engines Search Console can’t see, like ChatGPT.
Can your click rate fall while your traffic grows?
Yes, and it’s the easiest one to misread. Click rate is clicks divided by impressions, so it falls whenever impressions grow faster than clicks. Here’s KeptWell, a health guide site we own and work on the same way we do for clients, from its own Search Console.
KeptWell: clicks up, click rate down
From the week of September 26 to the week of November 7, KeptWell’s clicks tripled, from 17.4 a day to 51.6. Its click rate halved, from 1.11% to 0.56%. Nothing was taken. Its impressions grew almost six times, from 1,569 a day to 9,233, as Google showed it for far more searches, and most of those new impressions didn’t turn into a click.
AI Overviews didn’t cause the fall either. Impressions in Google’s AI features grew from 225 a day to 1,227, but they were about the same share of all its impressions in both weeks, 14% and 13%. So read clicks first. A falling click rate with rising clicks is growth.
How much traffic do AI Overviews really take?
On searches where one shows, a lot. In a randomized experiment, Saharsh Agarwal and Ananya Sen found 39.8% fewer organic clicks when the overview was shown. Pew Research tracked the searches of 900 US adults in March 2025: people who saw an AI summary clicked a regular result on 8% of visits, against 15% for people who didn’t, and clicked a link inside the summary on 1% of visits.
Across a whole site the loss is smaller, because many searches get no overview. In Pew’s data, 53% of searches of 10 words or more got one, against 8% of one- or two-word searches. Google’s head of Search, Liz Reid, says total organic click volume from Google Search to websites has been “relatively stable year-over-year.” So if your clicks fell mostly on short searches, look harder at the other causes first.
What do you change if the overview took the click?
- Get cited in the overviewAn overview links to the pages it draws on. Answer the question in the first lines of the page, in words someone could quote. Then give what a summary can’t: your own numbers, a tool, the steps for your product. Our guide to getting cited by ChatGPT covers the same moves.
- Make sure Google can read the pageA page Google hasn’t indexed can’t be cited. Check yours in the Page indexing report.
- Track AI impressions on the pages that lost clicksSome of those clicks won’t come back. On those pages, showing up in the answer is the win, and the AI report is where you see it.
Getting named in AI answers, from Google’s overviews to ChatGPT, is what we do for 30+ software companies. KeptWell gets the same work, and it has 20 times the Google clicks it had before we started, from 3 a day to 52 in 15 weeks. One plan, $2,000 a month. See what’s in the plan.